Judge to Rule on Appeal of Fines Against Wingham Coffee Shop

Source: WFP
Date: Fri Jul 5 03:39:42 MST 2024

(Wingham, ON) On July 11th at 10:30 am, Judge T.G. MacDonald will deliver a crucial ruling on the appeal of $6,900 in fines issued against Buck & Jo’s, a coffee shop in Wingham, Ontario. These fines were originally imposed by Justice Of The Peace Frank Leddy, who now faces scrutiny for potential errors in his judgment.

The fines stem from a series of contentious interactions between Buck & Jo’s and Huron Perth Public Health (HPPH) inspectors. The coffee shop owners, notably Buck, have publicly and repeatedly stated that they would lock their doors before the compliance deadline rather than infringe upon their customers’ rights. They argue that this decision was a political statement and should not warrant punishment.

Allegations have emerged against HPPH inspectors, including dereliction of duty, refusal to conduct inspections, and refusal to answer pertinent questions. Videos capturing these interactions have gone viral, amassing over 250,000 views, showing Buck firmly standing his ground against inspectors who failed to perform their duties adequately.

One key aspect of the case is the admission by HPPH that their inspectors did not have the authority to check photo identification and health information of customers. They conceded that without this authority, they could not impose such responsibilities on Buck or any other individual.

This case raises an important legal question: Does a business have the right to shut down before a compliance deadline to avoid legal complications? The outcome could set a significant precedent for similar cases in the future.

The controversy includes allegations of perjury against HPPH inspectors and claims of intimidation tactics. During the first visit by HPPH, an Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) officer accompanied the inspector with his hand on his gun, demanding compliance with the inspection. Contrary to HPPH’s claims, video evidence disproves allegations that Buck brandished a weapon during the interaction.

Despite the restaurant being closed a week before the incident and remaining closed for months afterward, it was fined $6,900, a sum notably higher than fines for some drunk driving offenses, which are typically around $1,500. There were also inconsistencies in the inspectors’ testimonies, with one inspector falsely claiming to have read online that the dining room would be open for indoor dining. HPPH issued and then deleted a press release that inaccurately stated they had shut down the dining room, which was already closed at the time.

The case has been drawn out over 972 days, with accusations that the prosecution has been profiting from the extended proceedings. Inspectors allegedly provided around 30 inconsistent statements during the trial. Justice Of The Peace Leddy has been criticized for his handling of the case, including admitting multiple times that he could not keep up with the proceedings and failing to obtain a trial transcript, leading to potential errors in his ruling.

Judge MacDonald’s upcoming decision will address these controversies and the broader implications for businesses facing similar situations. The hearing will be available for public viewing via a Zoom link. https://ca01web.zoom.us/j/64074406397?pwd dUNjcnE5K1k4R2N4TkxvT1JtUGtpZz09

This case highlights the challenges and complexities of enforcing health regulations and the rights of businesses in navigating compliance issues. The outcome will be closely watched by legal experts, business owners, and the public alike.


Blyth Bill

Hero Bernie Bailey Stands Up To Free Press - Morally/Intellectually Stunted NH Councillors Educated By Honorable Reeve Bernie Bailey #Schiestels4Bailey&SelfBlowies
Town Hall Overflows With Bailey Supporters - Public Unanimously Demands Current Municipal Council Term To Be Extended To 2028 #StopFakeNews
Reeve Bernie Bailey To Resign Monday Night Unless You Stop Him - Your Immediate Support To Save North Huron Is Required #StopFakeNews
North Huron A World Leader In Flood Management - Floodplains Proven True Cause Of Flooding








Area OPP

Fatal Collision
Brent SEWARD – Drunk Driving
Repeat Offender Arrested For Domestic Assault #WaitInTheTruck
STEWART Arrested For Drunk Driving
$500,000 Goderich Crime Spree – KURTIS GREEN Arrested Again
More Spousal Abuse #WaitInTheTruck
Drunk Driver Arrested In Kincardine
Pedophile Arrested Again #WaitInTheTruck
Huron Murder Update: Police Seek Witnesses
Murder Update: Police Seeking Public Assistance
Death Investigation In Central Huron
Scott CONNELLY From Lucknow Arrested – Details Released
Scott Weiler Was Arrested Again
Exeter Drug Bust, Two Arrested
Fatal Pedestrian Collision
$600,000 Worth of Stolen Property Recovered, Numerous Charges Laid
Do You Recognize This Theft Suspect
Curtis ANDERSON: Break & Enter
Break & Enters In Meaford
Kincardine Drug Bust: Name Released
Sharon TIFFANY: Impaired Driving
2 Arrested In Meaford – Names Released
Ryan SULLIVAN – Assault, Threats, Break & Enter
Travis Willard WAND: Murder & Kidnapping
More Impaired Drivers Arrested – Names Released


Huron County

New Child Care Centre for families in Exeter and Area
County of Huron Recovery Team remains committed to helping local businesses
Staff member at Huronview Home for the Aged confirmed positive for COVID-19




North Huron








Wingham Police Service